The Prague Post - Heated immigration debate complicates Germany's search for workers

EUR -
AED 4.225073
AFN 82.822883
ALL 99.674821
AMD 449.702847
ANG 2.073195
AOA 1055.409669
ARS 1293.792086
AUD 1.792007
AWG 2.070561
AZN 1.945189
BAM 1.979324
BBD 2.321187
BDT 139.680109
BGN 1.979804
BHD 0.433553
BIF 3370.412808
BMD 1.150312
BND 1.509291
BOB 7.9447
BRL 6.679815
BSD 1.149664
BTN 98.138382
BWP 15.846335
BYN 3.762448
BYR 22546.106159
BZD 2.309246
CAD 1.590979
CDF 3309.446058
CHF 0.931643
CLF 0.028826
CLP 1106.196809
CNY 8.399943
CNH 8.390188
COP 4924.483697
CRC 577.766802
CUC 1.150312
CUP 30.483256
CVE 112.039566
CZK 25.029641
DJF 204.433245
DKK 7.467704
DOP 69.602876
DZD 152.492221
EGP 58.128812
ERN 17.254673
ETB 153.018638
FJD 2.626971
FKP 0.865489
GBP 0.859967
GEL 3.157594
GGP 0.865489
GHS 17.898931
GIP 0.865489
GMD 82.245034
GNF 9956.53884
GTQ 8.855245
GYD 241.170523
HKD 8.925981
HNL 29.735542
HRK 7.528326
HTG 150.023035
HUF 407.481179
IDR 19352.726296
ILS 4.240497
IMP 0.865489
INR 97.959552
IQD 1506.908116
IRR 48456.873685
ISK 145.088581
JEP 0.865489
JMD 181.709633
JOD 0.815919
JPY 162.206551
KES 149.368256
KGS 100.3457
KHR 4618.501073
KMF 498.659336
KPW 1035.280385
KRW 1636.375427
KWD 0.35272
KYD 0.958087
KZT 601.812588
LAK 24947.376177
LBP 103067.914224
LKR 343.845631
LRD 230.033603
LSL 21.691303
LTL 3.396571
LVL 0.695812
LYD 6.292101
MAD 10.66919
MDL 19.888375
MGA 5237.245049
MKD 62.221505
MMK 2415.301798
MNT 4103.529009
MOP 9.191441
MRU 45.363144
MUR 51.867376
MVR 17.712359
MWK 1996.941223
MXN 22.671834
MYR 5.07
MZN 73.510625
NAD 21.691303
NGN 1845.847337
NIO 42.302772
NOK 11.936167
NPR 157.021209
NZD 1.916655
OMR 0.442867
PAB 1.149664
PEN 4.32861
PGK 4.754508
PHP 65.119198
PKR 322.781754
PLN 4.270144
PYG 9202.370866
QAR 4.187827
RON 4.978887
RSD 118.640046
RUB 93.43196
RWF 1627.690827
SAR 4.315955
SBD 9.578373
SCR 16.382384
SDG 690.751378
SEK 10.967358
SGD 1.501496
SHP 0.903964
SLE 26.19835
SLL 24121.439132
SOS 657.401436
SRD 42.734577
STD 23809.126381
SVC 10.059559
SYP 14956.186789
SZL 21.648827
THB 38.087006
TJS 12.347162
TMT 4.02609
TND 3.437158
TOP 2.694142
TRY 43.98895
TTD 7.800712
TWD 37.33589
TZS 3091.465244
UAH 47.643244
UGX 4214.233017
USD 1.150312
UYU 48.213015
UZS 14856.2739
VES 93.012615
VND 29784.441516
VUV 139.148944
WST 3.194419
XAF 663.858551
XAG 0.035189
XAU 0.000336
XCD 3.108775
XDR 0.825576
XOF 661.429223
XPF 119.331742
YER 282.114018
ZAR 21.51143
ZMK 10354.18632
ZMW 32.736071
ZWL 370.399846
  • RBGPF

    0.1400

    63.59

    +0.22%

  • SCS

    -0.3400

    9.42

    -3.61%

  • CMSD

    -0.1400

    21.82

    -0.64%

  • NGG

    0.7900

    72.9

    +1.08%

  • GSK

    0.5200

    36.45

    +1.43%

  • CMSC

    -0.1100

    21.71

    -0.51%

  • AZN

    -0.6900

    66.9

    -1.03%

  • RELX

    -0.1300

    52.07

    -0.25%

  • RIO

    0.3000

    58.47

    +0.51%

  • BP

    -0.2400

    28.08

    -0.85%

  • BCE

    0.3400

    22.38

    +1.52%

  • JRI

    -0.2700

    12.13

    -2.23%

  • RYCEF

    -0.2100

    9.29

    -2.26%

  • BCC

    -2.6700

    90.8

    -2.94%

  • BTI

    0.1800

    42.55

    +0.42%

  • VOD

    -0.0800

    9.23

    -0.87%

Heated immigration debate complicates Germany's search for workers
Heated immigration debate complicates Germany's search for workers / Photo: STEFANIE LOOS - AFP

Heated immigration debate complicates Germany's search for workers

Hospital manager Kathrin Leffler says she worries Germany's tense pre-election debate on immigration will make it harder to recruit enough skilled workers from abroad to fill a growing labour shortage.

Text size:

National polls on Sunday are expected to deliver victory for the conservative CDU/CSU bloc and a strong second-place showing for the far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD).

Both parties have promised a crackdown on immigration, with the AfD campaigning in parts of the country with fake plane tickets to send illegal migrants on a one-way journey home.

Potential new employees are "looking very carefully at which country they will go to in the future, where they want to live", said Leffler, director of care at a clinic in Berlin.

The recent political developments were "certainly not positive", when it comes to attracting the best and brightest from abroad, she said.

In German hospitals, some 15 percent of all medical professionals have a foreign passport, including about 5,000 Syrian doctors.

And the share of foreign workers is expected to grow as older generations head into retirement, without enough local trainees to replace them.

Some "40,000 skilled immigrants" a year are needed to make up the "demographic deficit", said Gerald Gass, the head of the German hospitals association.

The issue goes beyond healthcare. Across agriculture, construction, logistics and beyond, Germany will need "at least 1.6 million" new migrants by 2029 to fill vital roles, according to the DIW economic institute in Berlin.

Without them, it said, Germany's plans to overhaul its creaking economy could fail and "many companies will go bankrupt".

- 'Immigrant complex' -

Wassim Hadded, a 27-year-old nurse from Tunisia, is one of the skilled workers already tempted to Germany to fill a key role.

At the end of a week working night shifts at a Berlin hospital, Hadded told AFP he was "satisfied" with life in Germany.

Hadded was recruited in 2023 by the Triple Win project, which creates a pathway for healthcare workers from seven countries to come to Germany.

He said he wanted to "discover a new country, another culture" when he accepted the programme's offer, which included German lessons and help finding accommodation.

But the strange looks foreigners sometimes receive on the street could create an "immigrant complex" in their minds, Hadded said.

Germany's "welcome culture" under former chancellor Angela Merkel, who opened the door to over a million Syrian, Afghan and other refugees during the mass influx of 2015-2016, has soured in recent years.

After a series of deadly attacks blamed on migrants, the CDU/CSU last month passed a motion calling for an immigration crackdown with the support of the AfD -- a taboo-breaking manoeuvre.

The hardline stance was an attempt to "claim back this issue" from the far-right party, said political scientist Oliviero Angeli of Dresden Technical University.

The conservatives led by Friedrich Merz wanted a "change of direction", starting from the principle that humanitarian help and economic policy need to be "strictly separated", he said.

Even Chancellor Olaf Scholz's centre-left Social Democrats had "moved relatively strongly to the right" on immigration, with the government imposing stricter controls along Germany's borders.

- 'Incomprehension' -

Despite several high-profile attacks, an Ifo institute analysis published this week said there was "no correlation between an increasing share of foreigners in a district and the local crime rate".

It also proposed that "an effective way to prevent crime among migrants is through labour market integration" and called for policies that facilitate the recognition of foreign qualifications.

Scholz's government has signed deals with India, Kenya, Morocco and other countries to make it easier for skilled workers to come to Germany, but the hurdles remained significant.

"Highly bureaucratic" procedures could lead candidates to opt for other countries where entering the job market is easier, said hospital association chief Gass.

Nurse Hadded said he had to wait "more than a year" for his qualifications to be recognised in Germany.

Cutting red tape would not however be enough, Gass suggested. "The current political situation does not make Germany more competitive."

The tone of the immigration debate was met by many non-native residents with "incomprehension", said Mohamed El Kaada, the head of an association for Moroccans in Germany.

"We should not exclude those who have helped shape the country for decades," said El Kaada.

D.Kovar--TPP