The Prague Post - Why are proposed deep-sea mining rules so contentious?

EUR -
AED 4.177115
AFN 81.881407
ALL 99.252011
AMD 444.59148
ANG 2.049629
AOA 1037.159602
ARS 1294.14051
AUD 1.780172
AWG 2.047025
AZN 1.937816
BAM 1.956825
BBD 2.294803
BDT 138.092365
BGN 1.957857
BHD 0.428625
BIF 3332.101328
BMD 1.137236
BND 1.492134
BOB 7.854392
BRL 6.605299
BSD 1.136596
BTN 97.022843
BWP 15.66621
BYN 3.71968
BYR 22289.824581
BZD 2.282996
CAD 1.574122
CDF 3271.828234
CHF 0.930817
CLF 0.028662
CLP 1099.88957
CNY 8.306268
CNH 8.306019
COP 4901.486936
CRC 571.199327
CUC 1.137236
CUP 30.136753
CVE 110.77121
CZK 25.063093
DJF 202.11002
DKK 7.466603
DOP 68.807192
DZD 150.758867
EGP 58.143353
ERN 17.058539
ETB 151.279275
FJD 2.59711
FKP 0.855951
GBP 0.857288
GEL 3.116471
GGP 0.855951
GHS 17.695835
GIP 0.855951
GMD 81.31675
GNF 9843.350125
GTQ 8.754588
GYD 238.429138
HKD 8.82913
HNL 29.46444
HRK 7.519522
HTG 148.317723
HUF 408.38716
IDR 19177.096068
ILS 4.192296
IMP 0.855951
INR 97.094367
IQD 1489.779092
IRR 47906.064711
ISK 145.100373
JEP 0.855951
JMD 179.644139
JOD 0.806646
JPY 161.924776
KES 147.276378
KGS 99.205077
KHR 4566.00273
KMF 492.996098
KPW 1023.51235
KRW 1613.044532
KWD 0.348711
KYD 0.947196
KZT 594.971784
LAK 24598.413953
LBP 101896.34134
LKR 339.937138
LRD 227.418803
LSL 21.444738
LTL 3.357963
LVL 0.687903
LYD 6.221113
MAD 10.547908
MDL 19.662304
MGA 5177.713287
MKD 61.514233
MMK 2387.450153
MNT 4055.721375
MOP 9.086962
MRU 44.847502
MUR 51.278399
MVR 17.517685
MWK 1974.241998
MXN 22.425622
MYR 5.012372
MZN 72.675107
NAD 21.444738
NGN 1824.926761
NIO 41.821916
NOK 11.909658
NPR 155.236349
NZD 1.90379
OMR 0.437833
PAB 1.136596
PEN 4.279463
PGK 4.700463
PHP 64.495498
PKR 319.112616
PLN 4.278742
PYG 9097.767521
QAR 4.140226
RON 4.978937
RSD 117.291464
RUB 93.451578
RWF 1609.188866
SAR 4.267179
SBD 9.516785
SCR 16.196165
SDG 682.914367
SEK 10.940517
SGD 1.490626
SHP 0.893689
SLE 25.900592
SLL 23847.250746
SOS 649.934509
SRD 42.248737
STD 23538.488054
SVC 9.945212
SYP 14786.177003
SZL 21.403201
THB 37.92345
TJS 12.206811
TMT 3.980326
TND 3.398104
TOP 2.663525
TRY 43.238625
TTD 7.712041
TWD 36.987505
TZS 3056.325739
UAH 47.101683
UGX 4166.329832
USD 1.137236
UYU 47.664978
UZS 14768.739292
VES 91.955341
VND 29420.293975
VUV 137.567375
WST 3.158108
XAF 656.312471
XAG 0.034868
XAU 0.000342
XCD 3.073437
XDR 0.816192
XOF 653.911048
XPF 119.331742
YER 278.907529
ZAR 21.404946
ZMK 10236.492294
ZMW 32.36396
ZWL 366.189511
  • BCC

    0.7800

    93.47

    +0.83%

  • BCE

    0.4200

    22.04

    +1.91%

  • AZN

    0.5400

    67.59

    +0.8%

  • GSK

    0.5600

    35.93

    +1.56%

  • SCS

    0.0500

    9.76

    +0.51%

  • NGG

    0.6300

    72.11

    +0.87%

  • RYCEF

    -0.1400

    9.36

    -1.5%

  • RBGPF

    63.5900

    63.59

    +100%

  • JRI

    0.1600

    12.4

    +1.29%

  • CMSD

    0.0400

    21.96

    +0.18%

  • CMSC

    0.0400

    21.82

    +0.18%

  • RELX

    1.0000

    52.2

    +1.92%

  • RIO

    1.0100

    58.17

    +1.74%

  • VOD

    0.1400

    9.31

    +1.5%

  • BTI

    0.5400

    42.37

    +1.27%

  • BP

    0.6600

    28.32

    +2.33%

Why are proposed deep-sea mining rules so contentious?
Why are proposed deep-sea mining rules so contentious? / Photo: Jean-Michel CORNU, Valentina BRESCHI - AFP

Why are proposed deep-sea mining rules so contentious?

After more than a decade of negotiations, a new round of talks to finalize a code to regulate deep-sea mining in international waters begins Monday in Jamaica, with hopes high for adoption this year.

Text size:

The International Seabed Authority (ISA), an independent body established in 1994 under a UN convention, has been working since 2014 on the new rules for developing mineral resources on the ocean floor.

The huge task has gathered pace, under pressure from corporate concerns eager to cash in on the untapped minerals.

Canada's The Metals Company plans to file the first commercial mining license request in June, through its subsidiary Nori (Nauru Ocean Resources Inc.), which hopes to extract polymetallic nodules from the Pacific.

Here is a look at the proposed rules, and why they have sparked intense debate:

- What does this mining code entail? -

Under the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), the ISA must both oversee any exploration or mining of coveted resources (such as cobalt, nickel, or manganese) in international waters, and protect the marine environment.

For activists worried about the protection of hard-to-reach ocean ecosystems, this twin mandate is nonsensical. Some groups, and more and more countries, are asking for a moratorium on seabed mining.

With no consensus, the ISA-led negotiations have continued.

The ISA Council, made up of 36 of the authority's 169 member states, will spend the next two weeks trying to bridge the gaps on finalizing the code.

They are working from a 250-page "consolidated text" already riddled with parenthetical changes, and comments on disagreements.

But then there are dozens of amendments filed by countries, companies and non-governmental organizations.

Emma Wilson of the Deep Sea Conservation Coalition told AFP there were "over 2,000 textual elements that are still being discussed -- and that those debates were "not close to being resolved."

- How would seabed mining work? -

Any entity wishing to obtain a contract to mine the ocean floor must be sponsored by a specific country.

Those applications for mining licenses would first go through the ISA's legal and technical commission, which NGOs say is too pro-industry and opaque.

The commission would evaluate the financial, technical and environmental aspects of the proposed plans, and then make a recommendation to the ISA Council, the final decision-maker.

But some worry that rules already set by UNCLOS would make it too difficult to reject any favorable recommendations.

The draft code calls for initial contracts lasting 30 years, followed up with extensions of five years at a time.

- What about environmental protection? -

Potential mining companies must conduct a survey of the possible environmental risks of their activities, but details on these surveys are still up in the air, with negotiators not yet even agreed on how to define the terms.

More and more countries, along with NGOs, highlight that even the idea of surveying potential impact is effectively impossible, given the lack of scientific data about the zones.

And some Pacific states insist that the code explicitly state the need to protect "underwater cultural heritage," but that is under debate.

- What about compliance? -

The draft text calls for inspections and evaluations for deep-sea mining companies, but how such a system would work is under debate. Some even think such mechanisms are ultimately not all that feasible.

- Will there be profit-sharing? -

Under UNCLOS, resources on the ocean floor are seen as the "common heritage of mankind."

The mining code under consideration stipulates that each company must pay royalties to the ISA based on the value of the metals. But what percentage should they pay?

A working group has proposed royalties of anywhere from three to 12 percent, while African states believe 40 percent is more just.

K.Dudek--TPP